anotherrandomguy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Truth About NG]

WE Rate upon animations

I honestly don't think its fair that this is put in the top weekly or monthly or whatever because sure it is a good concept but it isn't an animation. truthfully speaking i could come up with an idea like that, anyone can, but if its just text it sux. God Tom an d Wade, what is wrong with you guys these days? Well whatever, good concept.

CountPoopoo responds:

You can always say "I could have," unfortunatly, it's not true. If you came up with it you would have done a flash, you didn't. Still <3. All critism is taken in.

[A years progress]

Very Well Done.

I know how everyone is sick of stickfigure animations and such, but the point is this website is ment for flash ANIMATIONS and that means i will rate you upon your ANIMATION and not your stick figure. Look This amazing piece of work has shown me that you have a lot of talent and patience to do something so smooth and well done. All i can say is that you got to keep up the good work, not many flash animators have a great handle on the effects that you are doing. Now i won't bother you (like almost everyone has) in saying that you should do actual characters because i was truly entertained and i can't wait to see what you have next whether or not it is a stick film. If you have time or anything, maybe we can work on something to gether. I am not that great but ill try and it would be pretty awesome if we did something together. my email is [e-mail].

Fr0zEnPh0eNiX responds:

Hey thanks, I'll keep that offer in mind.

[Killer sticks]

kind of a rip off

i like the animation and i can see you put a lot of effort in to it but i have seen at least 4 people try riping off ringfinger's battlefield concept. i mean its bad enough that it has to be stick figures, i mean there are websites dedicated to stick figures. I am saying i am pretty sick of the same concept or graphics. if your using stickfigures, try atleast to invent a new way to use them, i see lots of potential.
btw don't compare my animation, i mean i know mine sucks so don't try defending yourself by criticising my work. as i said i think you can do better than this so dont be offended

azruial responds:

"as i said i think you can do better than this so dont be offended"
I am open to all criticizm and would never be offended by any review especially one that has more thought put into it than three profane words strung together.
(thanks for the review)

[Goku SSJ for 1st time]

i find it hard to believe.....

I have seen that seen countless times and i agree, it is pretty much exactly like it. I really makes me wonder if you really drew out the animation. It is easy to trace frame by frame, simply import the movie clip in a layer 1 and draw frame by frame on layer 2. maybe you drew all of it, or maybe you got kind of lazy and traced parts, i give you credit since it must have been so time consuming. By the way, i read your responses to any sort of criticism and i am just saying that you don't have to be so touchy on the subject, not everyone will love your stuff. all i am saying is to chill, the majority loves it and i just have to say that i am impressed especially if you drew it your self w/o tracing. Look i know based on how you acted with other critics, that you will look up my animation or what not and start trying to defend your self by blamming mine, well don't. i admit it, i am not at that level of commitment to a flash project and i am working hard to learn and improve upon my own. the only reason i am giving a 10 is because you don't seem to handle a low score to well and i am assuming you actually drew it not traced. so good job

Barry-the-SuperScot responds:

Check out the MSN Group to see my storyboards, I drew it all.
And your review wasn't bad. I actually don't get pissed at bad reviews, I actually like them (in a certain way, I do prefer the good reviews though)! They are funny because the reviewer is often retarded and I have a right to give them a reply saying how stupid they are.
Did you read their reviews? Most are "its shit!!!111 you succkkk1!!!1!!"
Now really, would you let an ignorant little cretin like that get away with it? Giving absolutely no reason why they didn't like it? Of course not.

And I wouldn't look up on your animations and blam them, I'm not a petty idiot like the rest of those cretins. I only check some to see if they made a Flash movie because 90% of the time they haven't therefore don't know how much work goes into a flash movie.

Your review was OK. But why sound a 0? :P There is sound there... ;)